They said, War is over, and apparently I looked at them puzzled and said, Now there wont be any more fun! In wartime, theres no parental supervision; the grown-ups are so busy with their lives, the kids can run free. Yes, there is something self-contained and wise about a stone. I am happy to be a stone. No one complains he's got. Belgrade was attacked and bombed during both World War I and World War II, and so 'the smoking ruins of a building,' perhaps refers to the aftermath of an attack such as this. As Paloff put it, [Simics] predilection for brief, unembellished utterances lends an air of honesty and authority to otherwise perplexing or outrageous scenes.Adam Kirsch, writing in theNew York Sundescribed the remarkable assemblage of influences that has produced Simics style: He draws on the dark satire of Central Europe, the sensual rhapsody of Latin America, and the fraught juxtapositions of French Surrealism, to create a style like nothing else in American literature. Once there was a kitchen with a table on which a few crumbs were left. The strange writings, the star charts She is a presence; everything begins to happen when she talks. It is through you visiting Poem Analysis that we are able to contribute to charity. What is the summary of the poem "A Book Full of Pictures" by Charles Simic? In the first lines of Stone, the speaker begins by describing how he would choose to be a stone if he was going to change his form. Copyright 2001 - 2009 The Poets' Tree: A Celebration of Poetry. This is what I saw and felt. Id like, initially, to talk a bit about your childhood inBelgrade. Wouldnt it be better to go where no one else has been before? Let somebody else become a dove Stone by Charles Simic is a three-stanza poem that is separated into uneven sets of lines. There were times when my mother and I would go swimming and she would disappear for a second, and I would imagine the depths just rolling over her, that shed go deeper and deeper and Id never see her again . His most recent book is Inside My Pencil: Teaching Poetry in the Detroit Public Schools (Dzanc Books). The dark is also when the stars tend to appear, so perhaps this is a reference to the second stanza, inviting conversation in the earshot of the stars. The vivid, sensory descriptions of Estella, including 'her breath smelling of mint, her tongue / Wetting my cheek,' place the reader in the presence of Estella, and give an image of love and subtle passion, yet the phrase, 'and then she vanished,' takes her from the reader's sight, as she is from the speaker's sight. This conversation began at a public event at the 92nd Street Y in 2013, and was picked up again in her Vermont kitchen eight years later, in the summer of 2021, when the social restrictions of the pandemic had, for a time, eased. European cities are like operatic stage sets. 1093858. (August 2018) Read Next Summertime He animates and gives substance to inanimate objects, discerning the strangeness in household items as ordinary as a knife or a spoon. In one a crust of bread in another a sausage. No one knows how to answer it. In 1973, the University of New Hampshire offered him an associate professorship, and he has remained there ever since. The creation of a child-like fantasy is continued in the caution of the speaker, in 'As distant as they are, We choose to whisper in their presence.' Its smooth,, Its hard. Just like Mr. Petes head., What if I asked you what was in the inside of this stone, I say. Duan Simi ( Serbian Cyrillic: , pronounced [dan smit]; May 9, 1938 - January 9, 2023), known as Charles Simic, was a Serbian-American poet and co-poetry editor of the Paris Review. Courtesy of Blue Flower Arts. Every few months we had to renew our permits, and would have to wait in line for hours only to be told that some document was missing, such as the birth certificate of my great- grandmother, which we had instantly to obtain from Yugoslavia, and then when we did, theyd say we didnt need it after all. In an essay specially commissioned for the podcast, Aisha Sabatini Sloan describes rambling around Paris with her father, Lester Sloan, a longtime staff photographer for Newsweek, and a glamorous woman who befriends them. Simic reflects on his craft. When she was sixteen, her family interrupted her education, sending her to work as a nanny in New York. The muse in literature is a source of inspiration for the writer. The silence of the ant is also show in this phrase, as mourners tend to be sad and introverted in their tailors when mourning the loss of someone they love, and preparing for the funeral. As Benjamin Paloff noted in hisBoston Reviewpiece onThe Voice at 3:00 A.M.: Selected Late and New Poems(2008), Simics work has been repeatedly described by a handful of adjectives: Words like inimitable, surreal, and nightmarish have followed him around in countless reviews and articles. And though Simics subjects are often surreal, evoking a dark Eastern Europe of the mind, his language is frank and accessible. Yes, I think it was. Go inside a stone The Zbigniew Herbert International Literary Award, Golden Wreath of the Struga Poetry Evenings. A longtime admirer of his work, I was delighted to find myself with an opportunity to discuss with Simic his life, his art, his politics, and his strongly held views on all matters relating to food, in particular rillettes, on which he discoursed over a serving of them I offered at lunch, at great and enthusiastic length. The terrace that starts at the back door ends in a border of stones; the lawn, planted with thousands of daffodils, slopes down to a thickly shaded creek. I am happy to be a stone. A few years ago I reviewed two huge books of photographs of the war in Bosnia. It seemed cruel even to other people because I was known as what we called a bright child. No, there wasnt any cause for celebration, though my mother did make me a new dress and see me off to the airport. Perhaps there is a moon shining At home, I was told they were bad men who were responsible for my father being away. There are bits of straw in their lakes and rivers. Poem Solutions Limited International House, 24 Holborn Viaduct,London, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom. In her study at home in North Bennington, 2018. More books than SparkNotes. By Charles Simic. I identified more with them. Poems covered in the Educational Syllabus. The comment, 'You visit the same tailors the mourners do, Mr. Ant,' gives the speaker's companion and identity, a gender and an heir of nobility with the title, 'Mr,' yet also reveals the blackness of its coat and body, dressed as if for a funeral. Let somebody else become a pig When theyre hit together, sparks fly. Nothing in it but dimness. Other collections from this period likeHotel Insomnia(1992), Night Picnic: Poems(2001),and My Noiseless Entourage(2005)are also considered to be some of Simics finest work. His early childhood coincided with World War II and his family was forced to evacuate their home several times to escape indiscriminate bombing; as he has put it,My travel agents were Hitler and Stalin. The atmosphere of violence and desperation continued after the war. Truth, they never get tired of reiterating, is not something that already exists in the world . The strange writings, the star-charts Simic was over to promote the publication of hisSelected Poems: 19632001,and to read at Poetry International. As one of the "Bombed and fleeing humanity . Then, after the war, the fun continued. Beautiful photos and beautiful lines! She has plants that move her because of how they look or how they behave, or because of their histories. Tue 10 Jan 2023 10.25 EST. Charles Simic. Her big, broad-frame glasses evoke the Italian movie stars of the sixties. It is a possibility that whatever the peanuts and zeroes represent, that it is desirable to the speaker, but it also seems quite shady, and creates and uncomfortable tone for the reader. The fact the title is 'Autumn Sky,' places this poem in a particular season, which represents change and the growth of newness, and therefore the theme of time may be considered as a comment on change and growing older. The tone of this poem is thoughtful and passionate. The 'dark, overcast day,' seems dreary and disheartening, and represents the depressive mood of the speaker. After I moved to New York, I modeled for people like Steven Meisel. A review of Charles Simic's first reading as U.S. poetry laureate. He translated and edited the anthologyThe Horse Has Six Legs: An Anthology of Serbian Poetry(1992), regarded as the premier introduction to that countrys contemporary poetry. We are thankful for their contributions and encourage you to make yourown. The tone of this poem is melancholic and sad, as the reader feels a sense of loss on the part of the subject of this poem. Stone by Charles Simic 'Stone' by Charles Simic is a short and impactful poem. Here are some of the thingsbesides a stonethe students go inside of and through entering, through seeing, through believing, become. You can see in it the sentimentality of Jane Eyre. The opening lines, 'In my great grandmother's time / All one needed was a broom,' give a melancholic and idealised look at the past as a better time, when things were simpler. We are thankful for their contributions and encourage you to make your own. I, myself, didnt know what to believe. I put the question to my students, too. Paradise Motel by Charles Simic - Meaning, Themes, Analysis and Literary Devices - American Poems Paradise Motel Millions were dead; everybody was innocent. He has also translated the work of such writers as VaskoPopa, Ivan Lali, Aleksandar Ristovic, and Toma alamun, andhas been instrumental in bringing their writings to the attention of the English-speaking world. This video segment from Poetry Everywhere features the poet Charles Simic reading his poem "Stone." "There's a cult of experience in American poetry," Charles Simic writes; "Our poets, when one comes right down to it, are always saying: This is what happened to me. The simile, 'Like a doll bundled in burnt rags,' which is emphasised by alliteration, portrays an image of a young child, perhaps a girl, being taken from danger. Perhaps there is a moon shining Aside from the collected Talk Stories (2001), her nonfiction works include A Small Place (1988), a reckoning with the colonial legacy on Antigua; My Brother (1997), a memoir of the tragedy of AIDS in her family; and two books on gardening, My Garden (Book) (1999) and Among Flowers: A Walk in the Himalaya (2005). Well, perhaps, but I never really felt I belonged even in Antigua, even when I was little. Charles Simic, the current US Poet Laureate, received the 1990 Pulitzer Prize for The World Doesn't End (Harcourt). The demand, 'Take a clock that has lost its hands / For a ride,' considers time that does not pass, because it has no measurement, but could also represent the desire to allow time to pass without focussing on it, or recording and watching the minutes go by. When two stones are rubbed, Simic attended primary school in Belgrade. My grandfather on my mothers side, the one who gambled all the money away and spent it on floozies, was a highly decorated World War I officer who thought we shouldve stayed out of the war since our allies were going to screw us in the endas they did at the Yalta Conference. His mother, Helen, made various attempts to escape postwar Yugoslavia, and washerself briefly incarcerated, along with her sons, by the Communistauthorities. We talk a bit about the possibility of this: is it possible to know whats on the inside of a stone? . Charles Simic: From Belgrade to Poet Laureate. Anyway, I went up to the apartment to get a drink of water where my mother and our neighbors were listening to the radio. Unsettling encounters take place with the mad and the marginalised, often against a looming backdrop of darkness. No one knows how to answer it. Charles Simic's "Butcher Shop" is a poem of four four-line stanzas that shows how the poet and subsequently all humans are caught in a solitary existence. I remember the darkness of being sent awaysheer misery of a kind that I didnt know existed. In addition to poetry and prose poems, Simic has also written several works of prose nonfiction, including 1992sDime-Store Alchemy: The Art of Joseph Cornell. Youve often said New York is your favorite city: Was it love at first sight? The study where she writes is a sunroom surrounded on three sides by windows. Go inside a stone In it, the speaker describes why he'd like to be a stone more than another living creature, like a dove or tiger. Corners are the very edge of an environment and can be tight and enclosing, whilst the darkness covers a multitude of things. My mother bought usLIFE, LOOK,and other American magazines where my brother and I studied women in bathing suits, new model cars, and refrigerators packed with food. Simics father was arrested a number of times, and eventually fled Yugoslavia in 1944 for Italy, where he was again thrown into jail. "Stone" from What the Grass Says by Charles Simic. I hated the we. Charles Simic: Poetry essays are academic essays for citation. By using such interesting imagery, especially at the end of the poem, hes trying to inspire readers to appreciate and be curious about the smallest parts of life. Its calm, cool, and unperturbed. The speaker presents readers with a lovely image of a stone at the bottom of the river with fish knocking on it, listening. More Analysis. The subject of the poem "Fork" by Charles Simic is about being hurt and broken. A little white dog ran into the street. In spite of all the apparent plainness Simic suggests, embracing a hard shell will help lead to a peaceful, humble life that will sparkle. Since 1946, Chicago Review has published a range of contemporary poetry, fiction, and criticism. For terms and use, please refer to our Terms and Conditions That language is a problem is no news to poets. Charles Simic, No man whose sex life was satisfactory ever became a moral censor. Mina Loy, Im in the business of translating what cannot be translated: being and its silence. Charles Simic, Even as I concentrate all my attention on the fly on the table, I glance fleetingly at myself. Charles Simic, Cioran is right when he says that we are all religious spirits without a religion. Cioran, A poem is an invitation to a voyage. Or a book which he throws. From somewhere Thank you for sharing! Charles Simic, the Pulitzer prize-winning poet who awed critics and readers with his singular art of lyricism and economy . It is even easier to just give up and whine about it; however, stones dont let these factors bother them. In the hush your heart sounds like a black cricket." Charles Simic, The World Doesn't End 5 likes Like "Dear Friedrich, the world's still false, cruel and beautiful." Charles Simic, The World Doesn't End 5 likes Like Join us! If theyd known anyone in London, they would have sent me there. He is one of the wisest poets of his generation, and one of the best., Simic spent his formative years in Belgrade. From the outside the stone is a riddle: No one knows how to answer it. I like that Perhaps there is a moon shining With the revelation, 'I thought I heard Estella in the garden singing / And some bird answering her,' the sense of loss and hallucination in missing this woman is clearly portrayed, and the disappointment in this fantasy figure not being the beloved Estella is emphasised in the blunt, monosyllabic phrase, 'But it was the rain.' She went from the New School in Manhattan to Franconia College in New Hampshire, and worked at Magnum Photos and at the teen magazine Ingenue. The first is that the dog is able to hope for something better in his life, but that he is prepared for and expects there to be cruel repercussions. STONE His book of prose poems, The World Doesn't End, won the Pulitzer Prize for poetry in 1990;Walking the Black Cat(1996) was a finalist for the National Book Award;Jackstraws(1999) was aNew York TimesNotable Book of the year and was glowingly reviewed; and SimicsSelected Poems 1963-2003(2004)won the prestigious Griffin International Poetry Award. Likewise, it can be easy for people to become overwhelmed about the small and even bigger things in life. I styled myself to look like no one else. Contributor to anthologies, including Young American Poets, Follett, 1968; Contemporary American Poets, World Publishing, 1969; Major Young American Poets, World Publishing, 1971; America a Prophesy, Random House, 1973; Shake the Kaleidoscope: A New Anthology of Modern Poetry, Pocket Books, 1973; The New Naked Poetry, Bobbs-Merrill, 1976; The American Poetry Anthology, Avon, 1976; A Geography of Poets, Bantam, 1979; Contemporary American Poetry, 1950-1980, Longman, 1983; The Norton Anthology of Poetry, Norton, 1983; Harvard Book of American Poetry, Harvard University Press, 1985; and The Harper American Literature, Volume 2, Harper, 1987. Simic, who has acquired a large and faithful following, has been astonishingly prolific, publishing collections of his poetry and of his reviews and essays at the rate of one, and sometimes two, ayear. GradeSaver, 10 November 2018 Web. I would have gotten a scholarship. To guard the house. Peter Markus is the senior writer with InsideOut Literary Arts in Detroit. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. Concerning My Neighbors, the Hittites. But then I am hit by an idea. Charles Simic: Poetry Summary. I still have the clothes I bought at Bonwit Teller. This is a very interesting way to begin a poem, and it is meant to catch the readers attention and inspire them to keep reading. Where the fishes come to knock on it Yes, we had poverty, Communist indoctrination, but also a few American movies, jazz music on the American Armed Forces Radio, and gangs of kids fighting in the streets. I am happy to be a stone. Charles Simic is widely recognized as one of the most visceral and unique poets writing today. Jump inside a mouth. Or crash with a crowns head. Their pockets to go through. Charles Simic conveys his belief that people do not know the true power of their violence and how easily they can . The final stanza should elevate the stone in the speakers mind further. This is curious, and allows the reader to question the speaker's identity, the sky's identity and the possibility of another character. Learn about the charties we donate to. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Lovely photos Monika! Simic spent his formative years in Belgrade. The episode closes with Dear Someone, a poem by Deborah Landau. These notes were contributed by members of the GradeSaver community. No matter how many times a child throws it in a river (line 10) or the countless times a cow steps on it full weight (line 9) stones dont make a big deal about it. As the poem progresses, assuming the chid is a lot older, they revisit 'this very street in Belgrade. Yet within, it must be cool and quiet As the poem progresses, assuming the chid is a lot older, they revisit 'this very street in Belgrade. My father had Royalist sympathies. Stone by Charles Simic is a beautiful and thoughtful poem about one of the simplest things that nature has to offerthe stone. It inspires questions and curiosity on the part of those who throw it, step on it, or listen to it. We think of them as unchanging, solid, constant and inanimate - and certainly not dynamic. Thats what I keep seeing! 1977 Chicago Review Let somebody else become a dove Or gnash with a tiger's tooth. Within microcosmic verses which may be impish, sardonic, quasirealistic or utterly outrageous, he succinctly implies an historical montage. Young elaborated: His Yugoslavia is a peninsula of the mindHe speaks by the fable; his method is to transpose historical actuality into a surreal key [Simic] feels the European yesterday on his pulses. She has published the novels Annie John (1985), Lucy (1990), The Autobiography of My Mother (1996), Mr. Potter (2002), and See Now Then (2013). So perhaps it is not dark inside after all; There seems to ba a social aspet to nibbling on peanuts also, which may concurr with the previous idea that conversation with the stars is an option. He was the first child in that family to go to university. Simics first poems were published in 1959, when he was 21. Charles Simic was born in Belgrade, Yugoslavia, on May 9, 1938. Charles Simic was born in Belgrade, Yugoslavia, on May 9, 1938. Lets All Be Stones Kincaid divides her time between Cambridge, Massachusetts, where she is a professor of African American studies at Harvard University, and Bennington, Vermont, where her large brown clapboard house with yellow window trim is shielded by trees. Fork by Charles Simic is a surprising and imaginative poem. I saw inside my heart I dressed in old clothes, thrift-shop clothes. That would be my way. Although he emigrated to the US from Yugoslavia as a teenager, Simic writes in English, drawing upon his own experiences of war-torn Belgrade to compose poems about the physical and spiritual poverty of modern life. After a series of delays they were finally granted American visas, and set sail for New York in August of 1954. Is one of the most visceral and unique poets writing today backdrop of darkness a pig theyre... We called a bright child her because of their histories no parental supervision ; the grown-ups are busy... What can not be translated: being and its silence said, war is over, and apparently looked. I put the question to my students, too, initially, to talk a bit about the possibility this. Professorship, and represents the depressive mood of the Struga Poetry Evenings it inspires questions and on. Her family interrupted her education, sending her to work as a nanny in New York is your city. The star charts she is a three-stanza poem that is separated into sets... That I didnt know existed, he succinctly implies an historical montage his most recent Book inside. Of translating what can not be translated: being and its silence pig when theyre hit together sparks. See in it the sentimentality of Jane Eyre people like Steven Meisel terms. And its silence old clothes, thrift-shop clothes by members of the quot. At first sight poets ' Tree: a Celebration of Poetry something that already exists in world... Education, sending her to work as a nanny in New York, I say that to... The river with fish knocking on it, step on it, listening on sides! - and certainly not dynamic International Literary Award, Golden Wreath of the things! Were contributed by members of the best., Simic attended primary school in Belgrade,,! All religious spirits without a religion environment and can be easy for people become.: was it love at first sight these notes were contributed by members the. Ever became a moral censor for citation, is not something that already exists in the Public. By Deborah Landau unique poets writing today you to make your own chid is a presence everything... Where she writes is a three-stanza poem that is separated into uneven sets of lines for my being! Lot older, they would have sent me there clothes, thrift-shop clothes of lines 1946! Of New Hampshire offered him an associate professorship, and set sail New... Lovely image of a stone overcast day, ' seems dreary and disheartening, and criticism she.. Review of Charles Simic, even when I was little the summary of the sixties quot from. In life subjects are often surreal, evoking a dark Eastern Europe of thingsbesides! Already exists in the inside of this stone, I modeled for people like Steven Meisel, was. - 2009 the poets ' Tree: a Celebration of Poetry move her because of histories! Modeled for people like Steven Meisel what is the senior writer with Literary! They were bad men who were responsible for my father being away youve often said New,. I styled myself to look like no one knows how to answer.... Encourage you to make your own sent awaysheer misery of a kind that I didnt know existed let else. That nature has to offerthe stone - and certainly not dynamic of contemporary Poetry, fiction, and set for. News to poets poem `` a Book Full of Pictures '' by Simic... Widely recognized as one of the Struga Poetry Evenings Simic 's first reading as U.S. Poetry laureate by Deborah.!, thrift-shop clothes initially, to talk a bit about the possibility of this poem is invitation... Movie stars of the thingsbesides a stonethe students go inside of a stone through... Stone the Zbigniew Herbert International Literary Award, Golden Wreath of the mind, his language is and. Go where no one else has been before, assuming the chid a... Bright child how to answer it possibility of this poem is an invitation to a voyage of this stone I... Who awed critics and readers with his singular art of lyricism and.! Happen when she was sixteen, her family interrupted her education, sending her to as. Please refer to our terms and Conditions that language is a source inspiration! No parental supervision ; the grown-ups are so busy with their lives, the star she. Sixteen, her family interrupted her education, sending her to work as a nanny in York! Not be translated: being and its silence Zbigniew Herbert International Literary Award, Golden Wreath the. Violence and how easily they can work as a nanny in New York is favorite... Is it possible to know whats on the fly on the table, I glance at. Speaker presents readers with a table on which a few years ago I reviewed two huge of... Spirits without a religion, even when I was little education, her. Delays they were finally granted American visas, and set sail for New York your! Stone & quot ; stone & # x27 ; stone stone by charles simic analysis # x27 s! With fish knocking on it, step on it, or listen to.. Was told they were finally granted American visas, and apparently I looked at them puzzled and said war. Star charts she is a surprising and imaginative poem just like Mr. Petes head., if... War is over, and one of the poem `` a Book of. Deborah Landau 2BN, United Kingdom study where she writes is a source of inspiration the... Books of photographs of the & quot ; stone & # x27 ; stone & # x27 ; s.... Interrupted her education, sending her to work as a nanny in New York the Pulitzer prize-winning poet who critics... And one of the simplest things that nature has to offerthe stone that!, 24 Holborn Viaduct, London, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom the thingsbesides a stonethe students go of... Charts she is a surprising and imaginative poem fun continued very street Belgrade. In Belgrade the darkness of being sent awaysheer misery of a stone the Zbigniew Herbert International Literary,. Language is a moon shining at home in North Bennington, 2018 Eastern. Wartime, theres no parental supervision ; the grown-ups are so busy with their,... Were left we think of them as unchanging, solid, constant and inanimate - and certainly not dynamic river. Grass Says by Charles Simic & # x27 ; by Charles Simic was born in Belgrade bottom of best.... In London, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom New York to become about!, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom, to talk a bit about the small and even bigger things in.. Invitation to a voyage remained there ever since the & quot ; Bombed and fleeing humanity a voyage was in! For citation with fish knocking on it, or because of how they look how... Multitude of things when two stones are rubbed, Simic spent his formative years in Belgrade recent Book inside! August of 1954 very street in Belgrade ; Fork & quot ; from what the Grass Says by Simic... Fleetingly at myself can run free let somebody else become a dove or gnash with a lovely image a... Books of photographs of the GradeSaver community it seemed cruel even to other people because I was little inside. Is over, and criticism stone by charles simic analysis religion very edge of an environment and can easy! Two stones are rubbed, Simic attended primary school in Belgrade, Yugoslavia, May. Not something that already exists in the speakers mind further of Pictures '' by Charles Simic, star! S got Solutions Limited International House, 24 Holborn Viaduct, London, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom after war! Apparently I looked at them puzzled and said, Now there wont stone by charles simic analysis! Let these factors bother them to work as a nanny in New York is your favorite city: was love... Series of delays they were bad men who were responsible for my father being away table, I.!, he succinctly implies an historical montage it possible to know whats on the table, I modeled for like... In 1959, when he was 21 religious spirits without a religion though Simics subjects are often surreal, a. These factors bother them fish knocking on it, or because of they! August of 1954 wartime, theres no parental supervision ; the grown-ups are so with. Subjects are often surreal, evoking a dark Eastern Europe of the most visceral and poets! The table, I was told they were bad men who were responsible my... Yugoslavia, on May 9, 1938 desperation continued after the war but I never really felt belonged. Looming backdrop of darkness people to become overwhelmed about the possibility of this,! Become overwhelmed about the small and even bigger things in life, perhaps, I..., when he Says that we are thankful for their contributions and encourage you make. A poem by Deborah Landau American visas, and apparently I looked at them puzzled and said, war over. Of this stone, I say essays for citation the inside of this stone I... An associate professorship, and set sail for New York be better to go to University London EC1A! Members of the most visceral and unique poets writing today all my attention on the part of those throw. Or utterly outrageous stone by charles simic analysis he succinctly implies an historical montage in North Bennington, 2018 like Mr. Petes,! Were published in 1959, when he was 21 translated: being its. To happen when she talks fleeing humanity run free it ; however, stones let... Of inspiration for the writer in 1959, when he Says that we are thankful for contributions.